Slip and Fall in New York City: Can You Sue, and for How Much?
Yes, you can sue, and in New York City the defendant is usually not who people expect. A fall on a broken sidewalk is normally the building owner's problem, not the city's, under a law most New Yorkers have never heard of. But if the city, NYCHA or the MTA is on the hook, you have just 90 days to act, not three years. This guide covers who pays, every deadline, the snow rules, and what NYC falls actually settle for.
Who You Actually Sue in New York City
The single most important NYC-specific rule is Administrative Code section 7-210: the owner of the building next to a sidewalk, not the city, is liable for injuries caused by failing to keep that sidewalk reasonably safe. The duty is non-delegable, which means the owner cannot pass it to a tenant, a management company or a snow contractor by lease or handshake. Cracked flags, raised edges, missing chunks and uncleared ice on the sidewalk in front of an apartment building, an office tower or a store are the owner's problem.
There is one carve-out that changes everything: an owner-occupied one, two or three family home used only as a residence. In front of those buildings, the city itself keeps sidewalk liability. That sounds like a technicality until you realize what it does to your deadlines: a fall in front of a rowhouse where the owner lives becomes a claim against the City of New York, and city claims run on a 90 day clock, not a 3 year one.
Beyond sidewalks, the defendant follows the property: a supermarket for the wet aisle, a landlord for the dark or broken stairwell in an apartment building, NYCHA for falls in public housing, the MTA for subway stations and platforms, and the city for parks, schools and public buildings. Every one of those last three is a 90 day Notice of Claim defendant.
The 90 Day Trap
Claims against the city, NYCHA or the MTA require a formal Notice of Claim within 90 days of the accident under General Municipal Law section 50-e, and the lawsuit itself must start within one year and 90 days under section 50-i. The municipality can also demand a hearing about your claim before any lawsuit. Miss the 90 days and, outside narrow exceptions a court must approve, the claim dies no matter how badly you were hurt.
This is the deadline that quietly kills more NYC fall cases than anything else, because people reasonably assume they have years, and because it is often unclear in week one who the right defendant even is. The practical rule: after any fall in New York City, act as if the 90 day clock is running until someone confirms the defendant is purely private.
| Defendant | First deadline | Lawsuit deadline |
|---|---|---|
| Private owner (building, store, landlord) | None formal | 3 years (CPLR 214) |
| City of New York (parks, schools, streets it still owns) | Notice of Claim: 90 days | 1 year and 90 days (GML 50-i) |
| NYCHA (public housing) | Notice of Claim: 90 days | 1 year and 90 days |
| MTA / Transit (stations, platforms, buses) | Notice of Claim: 90 days | 1 year and 90 days |
Snow and Ice: The Four Hour Rule
Winter falls have their own statute. Under Administrative Code section 16-123, property owners must clear snow and ice from their sidewalks within four hours after the snow stops falling, and the hours between 9 pm and 7 am do not count. Snow that ends overnight generally has to be cleared by 11 am. Fall on an uncleared sidewalk after that window and the owner is exposed; fall while the storm is still coming down and New York's storm in progress rule usually protects the owner until a reasonable time after it ends.
This makes timing the whole case in winter falls. What time did the snow stop, and what time did you fall? Weather records answer the first question and are routinely used in these claims. If your fall came hours after the storm ended and the walk was untouched, that is exactly the case section 16-123 exists for.
What NYC Falls Actually Settle For
The injury drives the number far more than the location of the fall. As broad brackets, consistent with our national slip and fall settlement guide: soft tissue injuries commonly resolve around $5,000 to $15,000, fractures without surgery roughly $15,000 to $50,000, injuries requiring surgery often $75,000 to $200,000, and severe cases, head injuries, spinal damage, multiple surgeries, can run well beyond that.
Two things push New York City toward the top of those ranges. Medical costs here are among the highest in the country, and medical bills anchor every settlement. And venue matters: Bronx and Brooklyn juries are historically among the most generous to injured plaintiffs anywhere in the United States, which insurers price into settlements long before any trial. Against that, city and NYCHA cases carry their own discount, because municipal defendants fight harder and pay slower. The honest summary: identical injuries settle for genuinely different numbers depending on which side of the private-versus-municipal line the defendant sits on, and on proof, especially photographs of the defect taken before it was repaired.
Partly Your Fault? You Still Have a Case
New York follows pure comparative negligence under CPLR 1411: whatever percentage of the fall was your fault reduces your recovery by that percentage, and nothing bars the claim entirely. Looking at your phone, wearing smooth-soled shoes, having had a drink: insurers raise all of it, and none of it zeroes a claim. A $100,000 case at 30 percent claimant fault is still a $70,000 case. Treat comparative fault as a negotiation lever the other side uses, not a reason to stay quiet.
What to Do After a Fall in NYC, Step by Step
- Photograph the defect immediately, from several angles, with something for scale. NYC repairs hazards fast, and the photo of the actual crack, ice patch or spill is routinely the difference between a case and no case.
- Get medical care the same day and tell every provider exactly how and where you fell. The record made that day outweighs anything reconstructed later.
- Note the address of the building next to the fall. Under section 7-210 that address usually identifies your defendant.
- Report it to the store manager or building super if it happened on private premises, and ask that the incident be recorded.
- Keep the shoes you were wearing and get names and numbers of any witnesses.
- Assume the 90 day clock is running until you know the defendant is private, especially for falls near small homes, in parks, in public housing or in the subway.
- Value the claim before talking numbers with any insurer. That is what our free case review is for.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I sue for a slip and fall in New York City?
Yes, if a property owner's negligence caused the fall: a broken sidewalk, an unshoveled walk, a wet store floor, a dark stairwell. New York City puts sidewalk responsibility on the abutting building owner under Administrative Code section 7-210, New York is a pure comparative fault state so being partly at fault does not bar you, and you generally have 3 years to sue a private owner. The huge exception: if the city, NYCHA or the MTA is the defendant, you must file a Notice of Claim within 90 days.
How much is a NYC slip and fall settlement worth?
It depends almost entirely on the injury. As broad national brackets: soft tissue injuries commonly resolve around $5,000 to $15,000, fractures without surgery roughly $15,000 to $50,000, injuries needing surgery often $75,000 to $200,000, and severe cases like head or spinal injuries can exceed those ranges substantially. New York City cases frequently resolve above national norms because medical costs are high and Bronx, Brooklyn and Manhattan juries are historically generous, but the injury, the proof and the insurance available control every case.
Who pays for a fall on a NYC sidewalk?
Usually the owner of the building next to the sidewalk, not the city. NYC Administrative Code section 7-210 makes the abutting property owner liable for failing to keep the sidewalk reasonably safe, and the duty cannot be delegated to a tenant or a management company. The exception is an owner-occupied one, two or three family home used only as a residence: there the city itself keeps sidewalk liability, which turns your case into a 90 day Notice of Claim case.
What is the 90 day Notice of Claim rule?
Any injury claim against the City of New York, NYCHA or the MTA requires a formal Notice of Claim filed within 90 days of the accident under General Municipal Law section 50-e, and the lawsuit itself must be started within one year and 90 days under section 50-i. Miss the 90 days and the claim is usually dead regardless of how strong it was. Falls in parks, schools, public housing, subway stations and in front of owner-occupied small homes all commonly trigger this rule.
What are the snow and ice rules for NYC sidewalks?
Administrative Code section 16-123 gives property owners four hours to clear snow and ice after the snow stops falling, and the clock pauses between 9 pm and 7 am, so overnight snow must generally be cleared by 11 am. New York also applies the storm in progress rule: an owner is usually not liable for falls that happen while the storm is still going. The timing of your fall against when the snow stopped is often the whole case.
What if I was partly at fault, for example looking at my phone?
You can still recover. New York follows pure comparative negligence under CPLR 1411: your award is reduced by your percentage of fault but never wiped out. If a jury finds a broken step 70 percent responsible and you 30 percent responsible, you collect 70 percent of your damages. Insurers use partial fault to talk numbers down, not as a legal bar.
How long do I have to file a NYC slip and fall case?
Against a private owner, generally 3 years from the fall under CPLR 214. Against the city, NYCHA or the MTA, the Notice of Claim is due in 90 days and the lawsuit within one year and 90 days. Because you often cannot be certain who the right defendant is in the first weeks, the safe assumption after any NYC fall is that the 90 day clock is running.
What should I do right after a fall in NYC?
Photograph the exact defect immediately, the cracked flag, the ice, the spill, because NYC defects get repaired fast and the photo is often the case. Get medical care the same day and tell providers exactly how you fell. Identify the building address next to the fall, report it to the store or building if applicable, keep the shoes you wore, and get contact details for any witness. Then have the claim valued before talking to any insurer.
Sources
- NYC Administrative Code section 7-210, liability of real property owner for failure to maintain sidewalk in a reasonably safe condition.
- NYC Administrative Code section 16-123, removal of snow, ice and dirt from sidewalks; property owners' duties.
- New York General Municipal Law sections 50-e (Notice of Claim, 90 days) and 50-i (one year and 90 days).
- New York CPLR section 214 (three year limitations period for personal injury) and section 1411 (pure comparative negligence).
- New York appellate case law on the owner-occupied one to three family exemption and the storm in progress doctrine.
Related Resources
Hurt in a Fall in New York City?
Find out in two minutes who your claim is actually against, whether the 90 day clock applies to you, and what cases like yours resolve for.
Start My Free Case Review